By Brecken Wilkinson, MFT / Outpatient Therapist | November 1, 2026
With the holidays approaching, a question has been on my mind: Who do we become when we walk back through the front door?
Many of us notice that after living away from home—building our own lives, routines, and independent identities—returning to family can feel disorienting. There are plenty of reasons for this, but the one worth examining is the narrative we hold about ourselves within the family unit.
The Characters We Used to Play
Think about the role you had growing up. Were you the quiet one? The black sheep? The family clown? The peacemaker?
The labels are endless. The second we walk into that familiar kitchen or sit at the dining table, it’s easy to unconsciously slip back into decades-old patterns of thinking, reacting, and behaving.
But is that old role still true or helpful?
Maybe you were labeled the “difficult” kid. But people grow up, heal, and mature. You might still have bad days, but you definitely aren’t a child anymore—which means at least one fundamental thing is different.
The Labels We Outgrew
Throughout life, we collect labels from parents, teachers, siblings, and friends. A lot of the time, those labels weren’t even accurate to begin with. Yet they stick.
Years later, we find ourselves still believing them: We’ve evolved as adults, but the way we see ourselves within the family hasn’t caught up. We carry unhelpful beliefs about our worth, our role, and our place at the table.
Before the holiday rush begins, take some time to explore the stories you tell yourself and find one that is hurting more than it is helping.
Challenging the Script
Consider a common belief like: “I just don’t fit in here.”
That is a heavy, sweeping thought that colors how you experience every family interaction. If that sounds familiar, walk it through these steps:
-
Where did it start?: When did you first start believing that? Most of the time, that seed was planted when you were very young.
-
Is it actually true today?: Chances are you have people in your life who love your company, respect your perspectives, and make you feel at home. That is proof of belonging.
-
Does it even matter if you fit that specific mold?: What if you don’t need to fit into that specific family mold? Maybe that difference is what makes you unique. Maybe you enjoy your own company, and that independence is a strength rather than a flaw.
-
What is the real story?: What story actually reflects who you are today? You get to decide what your story is now. Try something that feels good to you: “I’m allowed to be different,” or “I don’t have to shrink to keep everyone else comfortable.“
What Happens When You Break Character
Living out this new story takes conscious effort. You have to catch yourself in real time when old reflexes kick in, take a breath, and steer back toward who you are today.
One quick heads-up, though: don’t be surprised if your family tries to hand your old script right back to you.
Families are systems, and systems love predictability. If the quiet kid speaks up, or the fixer stops smoothing over every argument, people get uneasy. They might ask what’s wrong with you or try to nudge you back into your comfortable box. That’s completely normal. It doesn’t mean your new boundary isn’t working—it just means their comfort zone is being challenged, not your truth.
Recommended Reading: The Story I Tell Myself
If you want to dive deeper into this process before the holidays, I highly recommend picking up The Story I Tell Myself by Peter Ash. The book explores the internal narratives that dictate how we see our worth and our place in the world. Ash shares lessons from his own journey and provides a step-by-step framework to help you spot limiting scripts, build self-awareness, and rewrite the stories you live by. We are the most impactful storytellers in our own lives—understanding your narrative is the first step toward lasting change.
Moving Forward
Changing these patterns takes time, but it is deeply worth the effort.
If you find yourself slipping into old dynamics this holiday season, pause and reflect. Ask yourself why that reflex appeared, decide whether that old role still serves you, and remember: you don’t have to keep playing a character you outgrew years ago.
If you are ready to navigate this season on your own terms, call or text us at 605-519-5850, or request to schedule an appointment with Brecken today.
Latest posts by Brecken Wilkinson, MFT (see all)
- Utilizing Narrative Therapy to Improve the Holidays - November 6, 2026
- The Space Between: Understanding Why Perception Isn’t Always Reality - April 1, 2026
- How Connectedness Helps Children Heal - September 30, 2025














